Visual arts activity
Photo Critique Club
Look at 3 photos with a grown-up. For each one, say 'I like...' and 'I wonder...'
Materials and setup
- 3 photos (phone, book, or magazine)
How this changes by age
Pre-K (ages 3–4)
Look at 3 photos with a grown-up. For each one, say 'I like...' and 'I wonder...'
Steps
- A grown-up picks 3 photos (magazine, book, or phone gallery).
- For each photo say: 'I like...' and finish the sentence.
- Then say: 'I wonder...' and finish that sentence.
- Vote on your favorite with a thumbs-up.
- Say thank you to the grown-up who shared.
Learning objectives
- Practice sharing an opinion
- Ask a curious question about an image
- Build the habit of looking at images closely
Kindergarten (ages 5–6)
Critique 3 photos together using 'I notice / I wonder / I would change'. Practice kind feedback.
Steps
- Pick 3 photos together.
- For each one: say what you notice, what you wonder, and one tiny thing you'd change.
- Use kind voice — feedback is a gift.
- Decide which photo tells the strongest story.
- Share one thing you'd try in your own photos next time.
Learning objectives
- Use the 'notice / wonder / change' critique frame
- Give kind, specific feedback
- Apply learning to future work
Early elementary (ages 6–8)
Critique 3 images using composition, light, and story categories. Write a one-sentence takeaway for each. If any photo shows a person, consent rules apply.
Steps
- Pick 3 photos from different sources.
- CONSENT RULE: if any photo you are critiquing shows a person in your family, ask them before you share or discuss it outside the household: 'Is it okay if I use your photo for my critique?' If they say no, pick another photo. Published or public photos (like from magazines) are fine to critique.
- For each, score 1–5 on: composition, light, storytelling.
- Explain each score in one sentence.
- Identify your single favorite and why.
- Write a 'borrow list' of techniques you want to try.
Learning objectives
- Apply three critique categories with specificity
- Justify opinions with evidence from the image
- Build a personal practice plan from others' work
- Ask for consent before using a family member's photo for critique
Upper elementary (ages 8–10)
Photo review session on 3 photos including one of your own. Use specific vocabulary and propose a revision. Consent for any photo that contains a person.
Steps
- Select 3 photos: one published photo, one family photo with permission, and one of your own.
- CONSENT RULE — taking a photo: if you ever take a photo of a person for this or any activity, ask clearly first: 'Is it okay if I take your picture?' Only take it if they say yes. If they change their mind afterward, DELETE the photo.
- CONSENT RULE — sharing a photo: even if they let you take it, ASK AGAIN before you post it or show it to people outside your family. Sharing is a SEPARATE yes.
- CONSENT RULE — kids in photos: if the person in the photo is a child younger than you, a grown-up must say yes for any use beyond your own household.
- Write 3 strengths and 3 revision ideas for each photo using vocabulary (leading lines, negative space, exposure, subject isolation, emotional tone).
- Rank the 3 photos and defend the order.
- On your own photo, pick one revision and describe exactly what you'd change.
- Share the revision idea with someone and ask if it would improve the image.
Learning objectives
- Use precise photographic vocabulary in critique
- Review your own work on equal terms with others'
- Translate critique into an actionable revision
- Apply separate consent rules for taking and sharing photos of people
Safety and evidence note
Read the full activity before beginning. An adult should supervise tools, heat, food, outdoor work, movement, and experiments as appropriate. Completion records that the activity was done; the child’s explanation, work sample, photo, or demonstration is stronger evidence of learning than a completion check alone.
Related visual arts activities
Artist Spotlight: Georgia O'Keeffe
Look at O'Keeffe's huge flower paintings. Draw one flower really, really big.
Artist Spotlight: Hokusai
Look at 'The Great Wave' by Hokusai. Talk about the big wave and the little boats.
Artist Spotlight: Jean-Michel Basquiat
Look at Basquiat's energetic crown paintings. Draw your own crown and scribble-words around it.
Blind Contour Drawing
Look only at your hand (not the paper!) and draw it with one line. The drawing will look silly — that's the point.