Home / Hands-on activities / Keep, Donate, or Toss?

Financial literacy activity

Keep, Donate, or Toss?

Sort your stuff into 3 piles: KEEP, DONATE, and TOSS! No need to actually donate — the learning is the DECIDING. For each toy or shirt, ask: 'Have I used this lately? Do I love it?'

Hands OnAbout 30 minutesScreen-freeParent help expected

Materials and setup

How this changes by age

Pre-K (ages 3–4)

Sort your stuff into 3 piles: KEEP, DONATE, and TOSS! No need to actually donate — the learning is the DECIDING. For each toy or shirt, ask: 'Have I used this lately? Do I love it?'

Difficulty 1 of 3

Steps

  1. Set up 3 spots on the floor: KEEP, DONATE, TOSS. Use a sign or colored paper for each.
  2. Pick one toy bin or one drawer. Take everything out.
  3. For each item, the child holds it and answers: 'Do I still play with this? Do I still love it? Is it broken?' Then place it in a pile.
  4. If the child is unsure, put the item in a 'Maybe' pile and revisit at the end.
  5. When done, count the piles together. Talk about WHY each item went where it went — the decisions, not the donating.

Learning objectives

  • Practice decision-making by sorting belongings into categories
  • Learn simple criteria: 'Do I use it? Do I love it? Is it broken?'
  • Build the habit of regularly evaluating what you own

Kindergarten (ages 5–6)

Apply a 6-month rule to your stuff: 'Have I used this in the last 6 months?' Sort an entire room into Keep / Donate / Toss using clear criteria.

Difficulty 2 of 3

Steps

  1. Pick a room or closet. Make 3 zones: Keep, Donate, Toss.
  2. Teach the 6-month rule: if you have not used or worn it in 6 months, it probably belongs in Donate or Toss.
  3. Add a 2nd rule: if it is broken and not worth fixing, it goes in Toss.
  4. Sort everything. Count items in each pile.
  5. Discuss tough decisions: 'Why was this hard to put in Donate?' Identify items kept for sentimental reasons (and that is okay).

Learning objectives

  • Apply a clear rule (the 6-month rule) when sorting belongings
  • Distinguish between functional value and sentimental value
  • Make decisions confidently using a checklist

Early elementary (ages 6–8)

Build a personal sorting RUBRIC. Decide your own criteria for Keep/Donate/Toss, then apply it consistently across multiple categories of belongings (clothes, toys, books, art supplies).

Difficulty 2 of 3

Steps

  1. Brainstorm and write down YOUR criteria. Examples: 'Used in last 6 months', 'Still fits', 'Still love it', 'Has a memory I want to keep'.
  2. Decide a rule: how many YES answers does an item need to be a KEEP?
  3. Apply your rubric to 4 categories: clothes, toys, books, art supplies.
  4. Track: how many items did you Keep / Donate / Toss in each category? Make a simple bar chart.
  5. Reflect: did your rubric work? Were there items the rubric said to donate that you wanted to keep? Update the rubric for next time.

Learning objectives

  • Design and apply a personal decision-making rubric
  • Make consistent decisions across multiple categories
  • Iterate on a decision rule based on real-world feedback

Upper elementary (ages 8–10)

Apply ECONOMIC THINKING to sorting: opportunity cost, sunk cost, and the value of space. Decide Keep/Donate/Toss while thinking about what each item costs you to keep.

Difficulty 3 of 3

Steps

  1. Learn three concepts: SUNK COST (what you paid does not matter — it is gone whether you keep the item or not), OPPORTUNITY COST (the space and time the item takes is space and time you cannot use for something else), and THE ENDOWMENT EFFECT (we overvalue things just because we own them).
  2. Pick your bedroom or closet. For each item, ask not just 'do I use it' but 'is this the BEST use of this shelf space?'
  3. Sort into Keep / Donate / Toss applying these economic concepts. Be honest about sunk cost — 'I paid $40 for it' is NOT a reason to keep something you do not use.
  4. Calculate roughly: if you have 30 items in your closet and only wear 10, what percent of your closet space is wasted?
  5. Write a short reflection: which economic concept changed your decisions the most?

Learning objectives

  • Apply sunk cost and opportunity cost reasoning to personal decisions
  • Recognize the endowment effect as a bias
  • Calculate the percentage of belongings actively used

Safety and evidence note

Read the full activity before beginning. An adult should supervise tools, heat, food, outdoor work, movement, and experiments as appropriate. Completion records that the activity was done; the child’s explanation, work sample, photo, or demonstration is stronger evidence of learning than a completion check alone.

Related financial literacy activities

Build a Brand

Create a name and a colorful logo for your pretend business! Draw it big and bold. Pick your business colors and make a sign to hang up.

Career Day Explorer

Explore different jobs! Learn about what people do to earn money. Dress up and pretend to be a doctor, teacher, firefighter, or chef. Every job helps our community!

Charitable Giving Hearts

Find 3 toys you've outgrown and put them in a donation bag for another child. Sharing makes someone else happy AND feels good in your own heart!

Coin Sorting

Sort coins by type and learn their names! Practice identifying pennies, nickels, dimes, and quarters by color, size, and pictures.

Browse all 575 activities · Explore course syllabi